《The Economist》《经济学人》中文版
ecocn · 2007-10-22
<< 量子加密法:“海森堡测的准原理”
|
首 页
|
麦肯锡:是什么影响着教育 >>
医学:输血也会杀人
2007-10-22
[2007.11.10]Blood simple血!血!血!
Medicine
医学
Blood simple
血!血!血!
Oct 11th 2007
From The Economist print edition
Because they lack an essential component, blood
transfusions may be killing some of the people they are intended to
save 由于一些关键因素的缺乏,输血可能杀死它原本要拯救的生命
IF THERE were any sure bets in medicine, you might think
that “blood transfusions save lives” would be one of them. But there
aren't. Even though deaths caused in the 1980s by accidental HIV
infection mean that donated blood is now screened meticulously to keep
it free of infectious agents, there is still a nagging feeling that
something is wrong.
如果在医学界有什么不言而喻的确据,那么“输血就人命”应该就是其一。但恐怕不是。尽管在经历了80年代爱滋病毒意外感染事件后,为防止感染但依然血液已经经过异常细致的检验与过滤但好象依然有些什么地方不对劲。
In 2004, for instance, Sunil Rao of Duke University
Medical Centre, in North Carolina, carried out a study of people
suffering from acute coronary syndrome (a specific type of heart
attack). One conclusion that could be drawn from his research was that
unnecessary blood transfusions might be causing tens of thousands of
deaths in America alone. Dr Rao found that patients who had had a
transfusion because of a low red blood-cell count had an 8% chance of
dying within 30 days. Without a transfusion, only 3% died. Those
numbers need to be treated with caution. As Dr Rao points out, the
patients who underwent transfusion were, on average, sicker and older
than those who did not. Nevertheless, his study is not the only
indication of something amiss.
对此2004年,北卡杜克大学医学中心(Duke University Medical Center)的桑尼饶(Sunil
Rao),对冠状动脉综合症(心脏病的一种)患者进行了一项调查。结果显示不必要的输血仅仅在美国就会造成上万例死亡。饶博士还发现因血细胞值低而接受输
血的患者中有8%在30天内死亡而未接受输血者中只有3%。这是一个值得认真对待的数据。正如饶博士所指出,接受输血的病人往往更加虚弱且衰老的更快。然
而,他的研究并不孤单。
In recent years, research has suggested that transfusion
is not necessarily a good thing for patients suffering from serious
injuries, for those who have undergone surgery and even for those who
are anaemic. And a study carried out earlier this year found that
critically ill children whose red blood-cell counts had dropped by half
fared no better after a transfusion than those who did not receive one.
近些年来,已经有研究指出输血对外科重伤并非一件很必要的好事,甚至对贫血也不是。一项早些年的研究表明血细胞值仅为正常一半的垂危儿童接受输血后并未比未接受者有所好转。
As a result of all this, questions are being asked about
whether something happens to blood when it is banked that causes it to
stop working properly. What that might be has remained a mystery. But
it may be one no longer. A group of Dr Rao's colleagues, led by
Jonathan Stamler, think the answer is a gas called nitric oxide—or,
rather, a lack of it.
一切都表明,似乎是血液在被收集起来的时候出了什么问题,使其无法正常发挥作用。这曾经被认为是个不解之谜,然而今天谜底将被揭开。一组饶博士的同事,在约翰森斯塔姆勒(Jonathan Stamler)的领导下提出谜底可能就是一氧化氮——不是搀杂,而是缺乏。
Out of gas
断气!断气!
The main reason for giving a patient blood is that it carries
oxygen. It carries lots of other things, too, such as glucose. But it
is a lack of oxygen that will kill you quickest. However, as Dr Stamler
points out, what determines whether transfused blood works as a
treatment is not merely how much oxygen it is carrying, but whether
that oxygen can reach the tissues that need it. This is where nitric
oxide comes in.
输血的主要目的在于运输氧气。而实际上它还携带其他许多东西,如葡萄糖。没有氧气人很快会死。而正如斯塔姆勒所指出输血起作用与否不仅仅在于它能携带多少氧气而在于他们能否到达需要的组织。这就是为什么要有一氧化氮。
Nitric oxide increases the flow of blood to tissues by
dilating the arteries that penetrate those tissues. The best known
example is the erectile tissue of the penis (Viagra works by sustaining
the signal that the gas gives). However, it is not just penile blood
vessels that nitric oxide relaxes. When a red blood cell reaches any
tissue in need of oxygen it releases nitric oxide in order to dilate
the capillaries. Only then can it deliver its cargo. And that is doubly
true of the cells in stored blood since red blood cells become less
flexible with age, and thus less able to squish into capillaries. Dr
Stamler thus wondered if a lack of nitric oxide was causing the
problems associated with transfusions.
一氧化氮通过扩张组织中的动脉血管来增加血流量。最典型的例子就是阴茎的勃起(伟哥就是通过这种气体产生的持续神经信号来起作用的)。而一氧化氮并不仅仅
只放松阴茎血管。当血红细胞到达任何需要的组织时,它就释放出一氧化氮来扩张毛细血管。惟其如此才能让货物顺利抵达。这点在血细胞上表现的格外明显:当血
红细胞衰老而失去弹性时,它将很难钻进狭小的毛细血管。斯塔姆勒博士因此怀疑正是缺乏一氧化氮导致了输血中的种种问题。
What he and his colleagues discovered, and published
this week in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, was
that the amount of nitric oxide in stored blood does indeed
decrease—and does so rapidly. Within a day of storage, blood loses 70%
of its nitric oxide. After a few days, up to 90% has been lost.
他和他的团队的发现已经刊登在这个星期的《美国科学院报》上。事实上在储存过程中一氧化氮的散失非常之迅速——一天便失去70%而数天则可达90%。
A second paper in the same journal, by Dr Stamler's
colleague Timothy McMahon, confirmed this result (in fact, it showed
that the initial drop of around 70% happens within three hours of
collection) and showed that it was not caused by the way blood is
processed, but merely by the passage of time. Dr McMahon also
established that stored blood does indeed lose its ability to dilate
blood vessels.
斯塔姆勒博士提莫司麦克马宏(Timothy McMahon)的同时在同期刊发的第二篇文章中证实了这一结果(事实上,约70%的含量在采血的最初3个小时内就散失迨尽)并发现这一现象与采血方式无关,而只是时间所为。他还确定储存过的血确实失去了扩张血管的能力。
Dr Stamler is in little doubt about the significance of
these findings. Furthermore, he warns that putting blood lacking nitric
oxide into the body does not merely dilute what gas is already present
in the bloodstream. Blood that is poor in nitric oxide will scavenge
the gas from other tissues, causing the vessels in those tissues to
constrict. If the tissue in question is heart muscle, the result will
be a heart attack.
斯塔姆勒博士对这些发现的重要性毫不怀疑,此外他还指出把这些缺乏一氧化氮的血液输入身体不仅仅是降低了身体内整体的一氧化氮浓度,而且还会从组织中吸收这些气体,从而导致这些组织无法舒张血管。而如果这样的组织是心肌的话,后果就是心脏病。
These papers, therefore, make a strong case that a lack
of nitric oxide is creating the problems with transfusions—though as
Michael Strong, the president of the American Association of Blood
Banks, points out, they do not settle the issue once and for all. That
would require a proper, randomised clinical trial.
尽管全美血液银行联合会主席麦克斯特朗(Michael Strong)指出这并非冰山的全部,但这些论文还是强有力的支持了一氧化氮缺乏是种种输血事故的起因。当然这一切还需要更正式随机临床检验。
And therein lies the rub. Because blood transfusion is
such an old practice (it dates back to 1818) it has never been
subjected to modern clinical standards. Nobody is questioning whether
car-crash victims, say, should have transfusions after massive blood
loss. Without it they would undoubtedly die. But for those not
threatened with exsanguination it is far less clear whether a
transfusion is a good idea. There are no rules about when to transfuse
and who to do it to. These are matters of judgment, and knowledge is
typically passed from doctor to doctor.
输血始终就是个大麻烦。因为它着实是一项太古老的技术(可以追溯到1818年)却从未被纳入过现代医疗标准中来。没有人会质疑为什么要给一个大量失血的车
祸受害者输血,因为不这样他无疑会死。但在其他情况下它和放血疗法一样没有什么原由可讲。从来没有相关规定,在什么时候什么人应该被输血。这是一个评估的
问题,而知识却只是在大夫和大夫间“口传心受”。
The good news from this study is that the problem should
be easy to correct. If nitric oxide is what is needed, it can be added
to banked blood just before transfusion. As part of the project, Dr
Stamler tried this with dogs. He found that old blood replenished with
nitric oxide is as good as fresh blood at relaxing blood vessels. And
that, he thinks, points to a bigger possibility than merely returning
blood to normal. Blood boosted with nitric oxide might be used as a
therapy for people who have had heart attacks by providing extra oxygen
in the crucial minutes after an attack, before the affected heart
muscle has died. At that point, blood transfusions would no longer be
part of the problem: they would be part of the cure.
但研究得出的好消息是这样的问题很好解决。如果一氧化氮是必须的,那么在输血前添加即可。作为项目的一部分,斯塔姆勒博士对狗进行了试验。他发现在扩张血
管方面补充了一氧化氮的血液和新鲜血液一样有效。因此让血液“返老还童”甚是可能。而将一氧化氮与血液一同输入则可以在心脏病发作后,病变心肌尚未死亡前
的关键几分钟提供更多的氧气。就这点而言,输血将不再是祸根之一而是治疗的一部分。
随机文章:
移民:流通还是一体化?
2008-01-10
电动车:小型电动车的市场成熟了吗?
2007-11-28
机器人:展翅高飞
2007-11-05
乙醇在左,甲醇在右
2007-10-12
银行:游戏玩大了
2007-08-24
收藏到:
Del.icio.us
引用地址:
发表于
15:54
|
编辑
|
继续话题
|
转发
|
推荐
发表评论
原始快照:web.archive.org