概念辨析(协作学习、合作学习、项目学习....)
未识别博客 · rjchen_et · 2004-01-28
life sharing
主题:传播思想、分享经验、个人反思
定位:教育咨询(工具、知识管理、时间管理、项目管理)
兴趣:支持网络教学的工具和平台、软件工程、项目管理、开放源码、教育信息化
|
主页
|
读《计算机支持的协作学习――理论与方法》>>>
概念辨析(协作学习、合作学习、项目学习....)
2004-01-28
合作学习vs协作学习:
(from 黄荣怀)“合作”与“协作”的意思非常相近,但“合作”更多的强调完成共同的任务,而“协作”是指相互配合完成各自的任务,虽然也可能任务是同一个;
个别学习VS
竟争
学习VS协作学习
个别学习
是指他人学习效果的好坏不影响自己个人的学习,个人通过自己的努力进行学习、管理自己的学习事务,与他人无关;
竟争
学习指个人学习的成功建立在他人失败的基础之上,学习者之间的关系是敌对的,相互倾轧,没有共享与互勉;
协作学习指个人学习的成功建立在他人成功的基础之上,学习者之间的关系是融洽的、相互合作的,共享信息与资源,共负责任,共担荣辱。
基于问题的学习VS基于项目的学习:
The terms
project-based learning
and
problem-based learning
are each used to describe a range of instructional strategies. The breadth of their respective definitions, their conceptual similarity, and the use of the shorthand term
PBL
result in some confusion in the literature. A brief survey of professional dialogue, Internet postings, and literature on project-based and problem-based learning reveals both similarities and differences between the two.
Similarities
As defined in the literature, project-based learning and problem-based learning share several characteristics. Both are instructional strategies that are intended to engage students in authentic, "real world" tasks to enhance learning. Students are given open-ended projects or problems with more than one approach or answer, intended to simulate professional situations. Both learning approaches are defined as student-centered, and include the teacher in the role of facilitator or coach. Students engaged in project- or problem-based learning generally work in cooperative groups for extended periods of time, and are encouraged to seek out multiple sources of information. Often these approaches include an emphasis on authentic, performance-based assessment.
Differences
Despite these many similarities, project- and problem-based learning are not identical approaches. Project-based learning tends to be associated with K-12 instruction. Problem-based learning is also used in K-12 classrooms, but has its origins in medical training and other professional preparation practices. (Ryan et al).
Project-based learning typically begins with an end product or "artifact" in mind, the production of which requires specific content knowledge or skills and typically raises one or more problems which students must solve. Projects vary widely in scope and time frame, and end products vary widely in level of technology used and sophistication. The project-based learning approach uses a production model: First, students define the purpose for creating the end product and identify their audience. They research their topic, design their product, and create a plan for project management. Students then begin the project, resolve problems and issues that arise in production, and finish their product. Students may use or present the product they have created, and ideally are given time to reflect on and evaluate their work. (Crawford, Bellnet website, Autodesk website, Blumenfeld et al). The entire process is meant to be authentic, mirroring real world production activities and utilizing students’ own ideas and approaches to accomplish the tasks at hand. Though the end product is the driving force in project-based learning, it is the content knowledge and skills acquired during the production process that are important to the success of the approach.
Problem-based learning, as the name implies, begins with a problem for students to solve or learn more about. Often these problems are framed in a scenario or case study format. Problems are designed to be "ill-structured" and to imitate the complexity of real life cases. As with project-based learning, problem-based learning assignments vary widely in scope and sophistication. The approach uses an inquiry model: students are presented with a problem and they begin by organizing any previous knowledge on the subject, posing any additional questions, and identifying areas they need more information. Students devise a plan for gathering more information, then do the necessary research and reconvene to share and summarize their new knowledge. Students may present their conclusions, and there may or may not be an end product. Again, students ideally have adequate time for reflection and self-evaluation. (Duch, Delisle, Hoffman and Ritchie, Stepian and Gallagher). All problem-based learning approaches rely on a problem as their driving forces, but may focus on the solution to varying degrees. Some problem-based approaches intend for students to clearly define the problem, develop hypotheses, gather information, and arrive at clearly stated solutions. (Allen). Others design the problems as learning-embedded cases which may have no solution but are meant to engage students in learning and information gathering. (Wang).
In practice, it is likely that the line between project- and problem-based learning is frequently blurred and that the two are used in combination and play complementary roles. Fundamentally, problem- and project-based learning have the same orientation: both are authentic, constructivist approaches to learning. The differences between the two approaches may lie in the subtle variations. There are at least two possible continua of variation in these type of learning approaches. One is the extent to which the end product is the organizing center of the project. On one end of this continuum, end products are elaborate and shape the production process, such as a computer animation piece which requires extensive planning and labor. On the other end, end products are simpler and more summative, such as a group’s report on their research findings. The former example is best described as project-based learning, where the end product drives the planning, production, and evaluation process. The latter example, where the inquiry and research (rather than the end product) is the primary focus of the learning process, is a better example of problem-based learning.
A second continuum of variation is the extent to which a problem is the organizing center of the project. On one end of this continuum are projects in which it is implicitly assumed that any number of problems will arise and students will require problem-solving skills to overcome them. On the other end of this continuum are projects that begin with a clearly stated problem or problems and require a set of conclusions or a solution in direct response, where "the problematic situation is the organizing center for the curriculum.". Here again, the former example typifies project-based learning, where the latter is best described as problem-based learning.
研究性学习:
rjchen_et
引用Trackback(0)
|
编辑
合作:collaboration
协作:cooperation
qwang
(
[Image]
Cooperative Learning Vs. Small-Group Discussions and Group
Projects: The Critical Differences
Subject/Discipline:
Submitter: Joseph Cuseo
Submitter Email: susan.ledlow@asu.edu
Submitter
Organization: Marymount College
Description: This article was originally published in
Cooperative Learning and College Teaching, 2.3
(1992): 5-10. Reprinted by permission.
Text Body: In ["Collaborative & Cooperative Learning in
Higher Education: A Taxonomy," Cooperative
Learning in Higher Education, Winter 1992] a
taxonomy was proposed to bring some clarity to
the myriad forms of learning that have been
loosely referred to as Collaborative/Cooperative
in American higher education. The present
article, continuing this quest for identity
delineates the key differences between
Cooperative Learning (CL) and two other forms of
small-group learning used in higher education:
small-group discussions and group projects.
Cooperative Learning may be defined as a
learner-centered instructional process in which
small, intentionally selected groups of 3-5
students work interdependently on a well-defined
learning task; individual students are held
accountable for their own performance and the
instructor serves as a facilitator/consultant in
the group-learning process.
More specifically, CL can be operationally
defined in terms of six procedural elements,
which when implemented together, distinguish it
from other forms of small-group learning in
higher education.
1. Intentional Group Formation
In contrast to traditional methods of small-group
learning, such as small-group discussions and
group projects, in which students often select
their own group members or groups are randomly
formed by the instructor, CL typically begins
with the intentional selection of group members
on the basis of predetermined criteria which have
been deliberately designed to potentiate the
positive effects of smallgroup learning. For
instance, groups may be dcliberatcly formed to
maximize heterogeneity and diversity of
perspectives by grouping students with different:
(a) levels of academic achievement (e.g.,
high-low-medium GPAs), (b) learning styles (e.g.,
deep processors and shallow processors), (c)
academic majors, (d) personality profiles (e.g.,
as measured by the MBTI), (e) ethnic or racial
backgrounds, (f) geographical backgrounds, (g)
gender, (h) ages (e.g., traditional and reentry
students) or (i) class standing (e.g.,
lowerdivision and upper-division students), or
some combination of these selection criteria.
The criteria for determining group composition
may vary depending on the instructor's objectives
or the characteristics of students in the class,
but the essential factor is that group formation
is not left to chance; instead, careful
forethought is given to the question of who
comprises each learning group in an attempt to
create the optimal social learning environment.
2. Continuity of Group Interaction
In contrast to traditional small-group
discussions or buzz groups, which typically group
students sporadically for a relatively short
period of time, CL groups typically meet
regularly over an extended period of time. This
allows for continuity of interaction among group
members and creates the opportunity for social
cohesion and bonding to develop among group
members. In this fashion, CL groups are given the
time needed to evolve into a tightly-knit social
network.
3. Interdependence Among Group Members
Rather than simply allowing students to interact
in small groups and then hoping they will do so
in a cooperative manner, CL incorporates specific
procedures designed to create a feeling of group
identity among students and collective
responsibility for one another's learning. The
following procedures are used to increase the
likelihood that this sense of positive
interdependence develops within CL groups:
(a) Group production of a common product at the
end of the Cooperative Learning experience.
In contrast to the usual discussion, or buzz
group which gets together for informal discussion
of some courserelated issue, each CL group is
expected to generate a formal product which
represents a concrete manifestation of the
group's collective effort (completion of a work
sheet; a compendium or chart of specific ideas;
an overhead transparency which can be displayed
to other groups). The objective of working toward
a clearly defined, common goal is essential for
keeping individual students on task and focused
on a group goal.
(b) Assignment of interdependent roles for each
group member.
A sense of individual responsibility to the group
may be increased if each group member has a
specific and essential role to play in achieving
the group's final goal or product. For instance,
individuals within the group could be assigned
the following interdependent roles: group
manager--who assures that the group stays on task
and t
xinglei
(
根据上面这个文章,我理解:合作应该是group learning的概念。
就我看过的cl资料似乎collaborate和cooperate是同一个概念
xinglei
(
cooperative task= interdependent taks
同一任务,不同分工(抬石头是相同分工),彼此依赖,缺一不可
qwang
(
如果以搬石头为例的话:
合作是已经分工好,两个人搬一块石头,两个人没有选择,只有共同努力把石头搬到目的地。
协作是:两个人搬两块石头,但如果两个人一起搬的话,会更省时省力。
rjchen_et
(
协作学习的outcome在于作为一种学习方式可以培养一些独立学习、竞争学习所无法,或者不能有效获得的方法
而不一定意味着在学习的过程中是一种最“经济”的方式。
比如:“每分钟打字120以上”这个教学目标,在cl中的评价标准将是“小组中每一个人都达标”,为了这个目标,早实现的学生需要传授经验给慢的学生来提早实现目标
xinglei
(
发表评论
最近更新
【暂停更新】
一个研究SharePoint的好站点
当你遇到以下十种人一定要珍惜!(转载)
第四课:描述性研究
W3C Celebrates Ten Years Leading the Web
读标准
【转载】构架师之路
一个有意思的blog
【转载】计 算 机 将 可 “ 预 测 ” 用 户 需 求
搜索引擎对比评估报告摘要
跟我联系
姓名:陈瑞江
专业:教育技术学
Email:crj@gse.pku.edu.cn
MSN:rjchen_et@hotmail.com
主页:http://www.et.pku.edu.cn/
原始快照:web.archive.org