如果我们兴趣相同,这就是您的精品屋,否则,您就随便转转吧^_
♀精品屋&杂货铺♀ · the other side are clearly evil. · 2004-06-17
如果我们兴趣相同,这就是您的精品屋,否则,您就随便转转吧^_^
|
首页
|
身为Lord of the Rings的fans(zz)>>>
2004-06-17 12:27
Most people in favour of drawing the line somewhere seem to draw the line on j
ust the other side of what they and their friends play. Some of the officials
responsible for drawing the line are older players who aren't nearly as succes
sful as they feel they ought to be. They're delighted for opportunities to pin
this lack of success on young upstarts and their "destructive" conventions.
Personally, I'm rather sceptical about the common definitions of "destructive"
bidding methods. Isn't stopping the opponents from reaching their best contra
ct as much a part of the game as reaching your own best contract. Just like fo
otball is as much about stopping the opponents from scoring as it is about sco
ring yourself. Critics of "destructive" styles and methods seem to regard them
as a threat to physical health, for much the same reason that in cricket you
don't bowl straight at the batsman's head.
If we're going to ban methods (and the reasons often given sound like a slight
ly reconstructed case for book-burning) a little objectiveness would be nice.
The ACBL approach is appalling - methods are illegal unless the powers that be
make them legal. Pretty similar to publishing a book in 1970s Russia. The ABF
approach - methods are legal unless explicitly banned - is much fairer. But e
ven the ABF lacks consistency. If you can open 2D as a European Multi, you're
playing a blue system (legal anywhere above some novice games) but if your 2C
opening shows exactly the same thing - a slightly simpler method to defend aga
inst (because it's one step lower) your methods are illegal in most pairs even
ts.
If a method is acceptable to play against, methods of equal complexity should
also be acceptable. I suppose in many places the 2D multi is acceptable, but l
ots of equally complex (or even considerably simpler) methods are banned or re
stricted. The argument presented is one about familiarity. If familiarity is t
he issue, it becomes apparent that the regulation was the problem all along -
the culprit is the policy of shielding people from these allegedly virulent me
thods. The other possibility is that the regulators are making specific exempt
ions for the methods that they employ themselves. Their weapons are OK, but th
e weapons used by the other side are clearly evil.
To paraphrase Larry Flynt, the right to play artificial methods isn't about th
e freedom to play the systems you like, it's about the opponents right to play
the systems you hate. An impartial observer would have trouble figuring out w
hy your 2C opening (good hand with any suit) is inherently good, and my 2C ope
ning (bad hand with any suit) is inherently evil. They wouldn't see why your 2
C (Stayman relay opposite 1NT - Stayman is a relay) is good while my 2C relay
response to 1S openings is bad. They wouldn't see why your 2D response to 1NT
(showing hearts) is perfectly acceptable, but my 2D opening showing hearts is
not. And they'd probably have difficulty comprehending why Flannery is virtuou
s and Ekrens is evil. And they probably wouldn't see why your 1C opening (at l
east three cards) is acceptable and my 1S opening (at least three cards) is wi
cked. It's all about familiarity and perception. Your 2C opening - an opening
bid with no anchor suit - might well make it hard for us to find our 500 save against your vulnerable slam.
Good hands have enough going for them - aces and kings take more tricks than q
ueens and jacks and considerably more then eights and sevens - but apparently
having good cards isn't a big enough advantage - people with good hands need l
egislative protection as well. The goals of ordinary and bad hands are just as
noble as the goals of good hands - they just want to achieve a good score wit
hin the laws of the game.
"Why are we forced to play inferior methods - methods which may already be out
of date" - Roth
"Once takeout doubles were permitted, Forcing Pass systems were inevitable" -
Kaplan (I think) Kieran Dyke (who hopes he got the quotes right)
王宁
@ 2004-06-17 12:27
返回页首
|
评论
|
引用(0)
|
编辑
评论
发表评论
最新文章
看文献
搞笑的训练
精彩的2004动漫之夜
幸福终点站
我为什么练跆拳道?
大青蛙过生日!
天气好了,心情也跟着变好
手机bug
过的好颓废
天越来越冷了,我会不会越来越懒啊?
原始快照:web.archive.org